• Latest
Not Everyone Wants a Bitcoin ETF

Not Everyone Wants a Bitcoin ETF

Dezember 11, 2018
6 Questions for Rene Reinsberg of Celo – Cointelegraph Magazine

6 Questions for Rene Reinsberg of Celo – Cointelegraph Magazine

März 31, 2023
Judge denies SEC motion to keep Hinman docs secret in Ripple case

Judge denies SEC motion to keep Hinman docs secret in Ripple case

März 31, 2023
The ultimate guide to Miami – Cointelegraph Magazine

The ultimate guide to Miami – Cointelegraph Magazine

März 31, 2023
Dr. Jane Thomason – Cointelegraph Magazine

Dr. Jane Thomason – Cointelegraph Magazine

März 31, 2023
1658007797 celsius is bankrupt with 12b balance sheet hole su zhu.jpg

Celsius is bankrupt with $1.2B balance sheet hole, Su Zhu returns to Twitter and OpenSea purges 20% of employees: Hodler’s Digest, July 10-16

März 31, 2023
6 Questions for Lisa Fridman of Quadrata – Cointelegraph Magazine

6 Questions for Lisa Fridman of Quadrata – Cointelegraph Magazine

März 31, 2023
Jed McCaleb empties XRP wallet after eight-year selloff

Jed McCaleb empties XRP wallet after eight-year selloff

März 31, 2023
Celsius has finally filed for bankruptcy: Law Decoded, July 18-25

Celsius has finally filed for bankruptcy: Law Decoded, July 18-25

März 31, 2023
The ‘godfather of crypto’ risked lifetime in jail, laying foundation for Bitcoin – Cointelegraph Magazine

The ‘godfather of crypto’ risked lifetime in jail, laying foundation for Bitcoin – Cointelegraph Magazine

März 31, 2023
SEC objects to XRP holders aiding Ripple defense

SEC objects to XRP holders aiding Ripple defense

März 31, 2023
Blockchain technology is transforming the real estate market – Cointelegraph Magazine

Blockchain technology is transforming the real estate market – Cointelegraph Magazine

März 31, 2023
1658612147 nfts banned in minecraft sec lists 9 tokens as securities.jpg

NFTs banned in Minecraft, SEC lists 9 tokens as securities and 3AC founder blames cockyness for company meltdown: Hodler’s Digest, July 17-23

März 31, 2023
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining
CoinNewsDaily
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining
No Result
View All Result
CoinNewsDaily
No Result
View All Result
Home Business

Not Everyone Wants a Bitcoin ETF

coinnewsdaily by coinnewsdaily
Dezember 11, 2018
in Business
0
Not Everyone Wants a Bitcoin ETF
190
SHARES
1.5k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

While many traders eagerly await a potential bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF), some of the cryptocurrency’s most passionate advocates are lukewarm at best about the prospect of such an instrument.

Twitter is flush with users like crypto entrepreneur Jonathan Hamel posting about how an ETF would bring an “epic” inflow of institutional capital to the ecosystem – that is, “billions” of dollars in new investments.

Related articles

IoTeX’s MachineFi Lab challenges Big Tech by democratizing IoT to benefit users and businesses

IoTeX’s MachineFi Lab challenges Big Tech by democratizing IoT to benefit users and businesses

Juli 26, 2022
ygg sea surpasses 10,000 scholarships in just six months of launch

YGG SEA Surpasses 10,000 Scholarships in Just Six Months of Launch

Mai 6, 2022

But if you talk to early adopters and veteran technologists in the bitcoin community, you’ll hear resounding indifference, if not queasiness.

“I don’t think an ETF is going to be some kind of massive magnet,” Pierre Rochard, founder of the Brooklyn-based Bitcoin Advisory LLC, told CoinDesk. “Substantively, it’s really not that much different than fractional reserve banking.”

Last week, the U.S. Securities and Exchange postponed plans to reevaluate ETF proposals from financial institutions such as VanEck and SolidX to as late as February 27, 2019. This means two more months of nail-biting for those who believe the ETF would be a huge boon to bitcoin or the savior of the overall crypto marketplace.

And yet, in reference to Grayscale’s Bitcoin Investment Trust, which launched in 2015, bitcoin analyst Nik Bhatia told CoinDesk:

“I don’t see the additional ETFs improving bitcoin’s liquidity any more than the GBTC already does.”

Although Bhatia said he would nevertheless welcome a regulator-approved ETF because it might increase public trust in this new asset class, some crypto veterans went as far as to say an ETF could actually be harmful to the broader ecosystem. To them, an ETF contradicts the vision of a peer-to-peer financial network fueled by self-custodied assets.

“It’s kind of a centralizing force and the value proposition of bitcoin is it’s decentralized, global,” Lightning Labs developer Alex Bosworth told CoinDesk.

Centralizing force

For Bosworth, the biggest risk that a bitcoin ETF presents is that it might incentivize institutions to work collectively to influence the ecosystem.

Referring to the thwarted New York Agreement in 2017 – when leading crypto companies planned to support unpopular bitcoin network updates simultaneously despite public outcry – Bosworth explained:

“We saw companies that are custodians for other people’s coins, talking as if they hold those coins and take actions that decide, on behalf of their users, without even consulting them…We don’t want to have central parties out there negotiating for fundamental rule changes in bitcoin.”

This is the same reason that bitcoin veteran Christopher Allen, the former principal architect at Blockstream, distrusts the institutions that are working to create a regulated bitcoin ETF.

“The real reason they are doing it is they can play financial games to make them a much higher interest rate than what they would otherwise,” Allen told CoinDesk. “I think there are a lot of implications of that. How do we educate people on what fiduciary responsibility and custody really is?”

Bhatia agreed that the industry is transitioning to prioritize a “trusted custody model,” but doesn’t think such institutional products will have a significant impact on cypherpunk traditionalists.

“People that currently store their own bitcoin aren’t going to rush into the ETF because they’re not looking for the same things,” he said.

Don’t hold your breath

Other bitcoin veterans are concerned retail investors are putting more faith in an ETF’s ability to rescue sinking cryptocurrency prices than the prospective product actually deserves.

If approved in the near future, Rochard said, he expects bitcoin ETFs would make up an even smaller percentage of the market than gold ETFs, which he estimated represent less than 2 percent of the global gold supply.

“We’re talking about a very niche part of the market that would be interested in a bitcoin ETF product,” Rochard said. “It would be even less than gold is used in an ETF because the overall settlement cost of bitcoin is lower than those of physically settling gold.”

Others say any boost to the price might be short-lived.

During CoinDesk’s Consensus: Invest conference in November, BlockTower Capital’s chief investment officer Ari Paul warned the audience to recall how the addition of bitcoin futures boosted short-term speculation far more than institutional commitment. The price settled back down within months.

“If an ETF was launched, it’s not that there would suddenly be massive institutional flows. I think on the announcement you’d get a massive rally,” Paul said. “That’s not because you suddenly get $50 million [in] institutional investors’ money, it’s because speculators price it in.”

And it’s important to remember that any euphoria (or anxiety) about a bitcoin ETF is still academic.

On December 5, SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce told the audience during fireside chat in Washington D.C. not to “hold your breath,” because a regulator-approved bitcoin ETF could still be years away. She added:

“I do caution people to not live or die on when a crypto or bitcoin ETF gets approved.”

Operational questions

Even if an ETF were to be approved, bitcoin advocates question how this structure – in which a fund owns underlying assets and divides ownership of them into shares – would address the idiosyncrasies of cryptocurrency.

For example, what if there’s another fork of the network, like the one that create bitcoin cash last year?

“Do they [ETF custodians] give the coins back to people or do they suddenly become an index fund?” Rochard said. “I don’t think there’s a precedent at all [from capital markets], because bitcoin doesn’t have a legal identity and corporations do.”

Allen said ETF issuers would need to clarify how they store and tally their bitcoin, so that products representing this underlying assets wouldn’t be loaned out over and over in a process called rehypothecation. As Caitlin Long, co-founder of the Wyoming Blockchain Coalition, wrote in a Forbes column, rehypothecation is antithetical to the bitcoin ethos because there is a finite bitcoin supply, 21 million at max.

As such, there’s no way to bail out lenders if borrowers were owed more bitcoin than the ETF-issuer actually possessed.

However, Gabor Gurbacs, the director of digital asset strategy for VanEck, told CoinDesk his company’s proposal would involve cold storage, daily disclosures to defuse any concerns about rehypothecation, and a handbook of regulator-approved index fund procedures to follow in the case of a bitcoin fork.

“We intend to stay true to the core tenets of bitcoin,” Gurbacs said, adding that ETF holders would be primarily exposed to the asset defined by Bitcoin Core unless another chain became dominant and equally secure.

“I don’t see any operational issues. I think we’ve figured it out and we’re waiting for the regulators to make a decision on this,” he went on to explain.

Like many bitcoin advocates, Rochard said that anything which boosts bitcoin’s overall liquidity – even modestly – is a good thing.

On the other hand, he sympathized with the skeptical indifference many technologists feel toward financial institutions.

“It would be really unfortunate if people lose sight of why bitcoin has value,” Rochard said. “But it would be such a small part of the market, so there’d be limited impact on that.”

Businessman on dart board image via Shutterstock



Credit: Source link

Tags: BusinessCryptoCrypto Business
Share76Tweet48
Previous Post

Fund Seeks $200 Million to Help Startups Survive a Crypto Winter

Next Post

Crypto Assets on Gibraltar Blockchain Exchange Can Now Be Insured

coinnewsdaily

coinnewsdaily

CoinNewsDaily.com is an online Crypto Coin News Website that aims to provide latest trendy news from market and around the world.

Related Posts

IoTeX’s MachineFi Lab challenges Big Tech by democratizing IoT to benefit users and businesses
Business

IoTeX’s MachineFi Lab challenges Big Tech by democratizing IoT to benefit users and businesses

Juli 26, 2022
ygg sea surpasses 10,000 scholarships in just six months of launch
Alt Coin

YGG SEA Surpasses 10,000 Scholarships in Just Six Months of Launch

Mai 6, 2022
5 projects enabling smart contract development on bitcoin
Alt Coin

5 Projects Enabling Smart Contract Development on Bitcoin

April 29, 2022
cross chain services play a crucial role in facilitating continued adoption of defi applications
Alt Coin

Cross-Chain Services Play a Crucial Role in Facilitating Continued Adoption of DeFi Applications

April 26, 2022
justin sun launches usdd, integrating the blockchain world and the real world with the decentralized stablecoin
Alt Coin

Justin Sun Launches USDD, Integrating the Blockchain World and the Real World with the Decentralized Stablecoin

April 25, 2022
what are wrapped tokens?
Bitcoin

What Are Wrapped Tokens?

April 23, 2022
Load More
Next Post
Crypto Assets on Gibraltar Blockchain Exchange Can Now Be Insured

Crypto Assets on Gibraltar Blockchain Exchange Can Now Be Insured

Kategorien

  • Alt Coin
  • Bitcoin
  • Business
  • Ethereum
  • ICO
  • Litecoin
  • Mining
  • NFT
  • Ripple
  • Tech
  • Trading

What New here?

  • 6 Questions for Rene Reinsberg of Celo – Cointelegraph Magazine
  • Judge denies SEC motion to keep Hinman docs secret in Ripple case
  • The ultimate guide to Miami – Cointelegraph Magazine
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy & Policy

© 2018-2021 CoinNewsDaily.com by CoinNewsDaily Inc. Crafted with Love by iFtiDev

Please enter CoinMarketCap Free Api Key to get this plugin works.
✕
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining

© 2018-2021 CoinNewsDaily.com by CoinNewsDaily Inc. Crafted with Love by iFtiDev