• Latest
When the Dust Settles: The Bitfinex Probe Reveals Structural Weaknesses

When the Dust Settles: The Bitfinex Probe Reveals Structural Weaknesses

May 12, 2019
ygg sea surpasses 10,000 scholarships in just six months of launch

YGG SEA Surpasses 10,000 Scholarships in Just Six Months of Launch

May 6, 2022
mintable launches industry changing gas free minting service on ethereum

Mintable Launches Industry Changing Gas Free Minting Service on Ethereum

May 1, 2022
5 projects enabling smart contract development on bitcoin

5 Projects Enabling Smart Contract Development on Bitcoin

April 29, 2022
bitcoin atm installed in mexico's senate building

Bitcoin ATM installed in Mexico’s Senate Building

April 27, 2022
cross chain services play a crucial role in facilitating continued adoption of defi applications

Cross-Chain Services Play a Crucial Role in Facilitating Continued Adoption of DeFi Applications

April 26, 2022
justin sun launches usdd, integrating the blockchain world and the real world with the decentralized stablecoin

Justin Sun Launches USDD, Integrating the Blockchain World and the Real World with the Decentralized Stablecoin

April 25, 2022
nfts: the next musical revolution

NFTs: The Next Musical Revolution

April 24, 2022
things you should know before investing in nfts

Things You Should Know Before Investing in NFTs

April 24, 2022
what are wrapped tokens?

What Are Wrapped Tokens?

April 23, 2022
what is the future of ethereum (eth)?

What is the future of Ethereum (ETH)?

April 22, 2022
green gaming

Everything You Need to Know About Play-to-Earn on Algorand in 2022

April 21, 2022
$ape going bananas as rumors of upcoming land sale of bayc metaverse gather momentum

$APE Going Bananas As Rumors of Upcoming Land Sale of BAYC Metaverse Gather Momentum

April 21, 2022
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining
CoinNewsDaily
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining
No Result
View All Result
CoinNewsDaily
No Result
View All Result
Home Business

When the Dust Settles: The Bitfinex Probe Reveals Structural Weaknesses

coinnewsdaily by coinnewsdaily
May 12, 2019
in Business
0
When the Dust Settles: The Bitfinex Probe Reveals Structural Weaknesses
190
SHARES
1.5k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Noelle Acheson is a veteran of company analysis and a member of CoinDesk’s product team.

The following article originally appeared in Institutional Crypto by CoinDesk, a free newsletter for the institutional market with news and views on crypto infrastructure delivered every Tuesday. Sign up here. 

Related articles

ygg sea surpasses 10,000 scholarships in just six months of launch

YGG SEA Surpasses 10,000 Scholarships in Just Six Months of Launch

May 6, 2022
5 projects enabling smart contract development on bitcoin

5 Projects Enabling Smart Contract Development on Bitcoin

April 29, 2022

Just as an earthquake reveals structural problems in buildings, so the news of the Bitfinex probe has laid bare two fundamental weaknesses in crypto infrastructure as a whole. While one is fairly public and much talked about, the other is more surprising and stems from trends developing far beyond the emergence of a new asset class.

Some background if you haven’t been following the news: Last week the New York Attorney General announced an initial probe into (among other things) a cover-up to hide the loss of $850 million of comingled client and corporate funds. Hong Kong-based Bitfinex is one of the sector’s leading cryptocurrency exchanges in terms of overall trading volume, and shares ownership structure with US$-backed tether, which accounts for over 90 percent of the global stablecoin market. Apparently, its payment processor Crypto Capital “lost” $850 million of Bitfinex funds some time in 2018; to cover the shortfall and meet user withdrawals, Bitfinex drew on Tether funds without disclosing the arrangement.

Obviously, many market participants run above-board operations and are continually working to improve their compliance with shifting regulations. But for large swathes of the sector, that is economically, strategically or perhaps even philosophically out of the question.

And even though the sector’s troubles may seem offshore, both literally and figuratively, the fallout has broad implications. For while stronger buildings can withstand tremors, the collateral damage from the collapse of weak structures erected during a growth-fueled rapid build-up can impact both public perception and policy, with lasting consequences.

These consequences are generally constructive, however, as people learn what to look out for, building codes become more rigorous and fault lines are worked around.

In the crypto sector, these fault lines are: 1) the lack of high-level banking services; and, 2) the somewhat overlooked lack of auditing standards.

Lack of banking

While some exchanges have managed to open and keep accounts at large and reputable banks, all will confirm that it was not easy and that it cannot be taken for granted – accounts can be closed at a moment’s notice.

Many have not been able to progress that far, either for jurisdictional issues, concerns over procedures or even the slightest whiff of potential proceeds from money laundering.

Smaller financial operations have emerged to fill the gap, but they tend to lack correspondent networks, payment processing and the reassurance of large balance sheets. Some, as we have seen, even lack any sort of oversight.

Bitfinex has had a long history of banking troubles, which on several occasions has fuelled rumors of insolvency as users struggled to withdraw funds. A report last year indicated that it had procured the services of European bank ING, but it is as yet unclear why, if that relationship was still ongoing, it would need to use the services of an offshore payment processor such as Crypto Capital.

What’s more, the lack of reliable banking enhances the demand for a solution like tether, which enables clients and exchanges to transfer value without the need for payment processors. Better banking will reduce the dependence on stablecoins with unverified backing.

The issue is starting to attract the attention of regulators who realise that investors are more likely to suffer where there is no strong banking support. Last week France announced a possible solution: bank accounts in exchange for regulation. Hopefully this initiative will spread to other jurisdictions, as confidence in cash flows will benefit not only potential users and investors but also the entrepreneurs and developers working to push adoption forward.

Lack of auditing standards

Tether has also had its share of troubles, stemming largely from lack of confidence in the amount of fiat currency allegedly backing the stablecoin. While Bitfinex often assured the public that tethers were fully backed by US dollars, it now turns out those assurances were misleading.

Amid repeated calls for an audit of Tether’s reserves, the company’s relationship with one auditor dissolved in early 2018. A letter produced by the Bahamas-based bank Deltec, which confirmed existence of a funded account, was met with scorn and skepticism.

Why is getting an audit so complicated?

Part of the problem is vocabulary. We say “audit” when we mean “attestation,” and they are not the same thing at all.

An “attestation” can confirm an assertion (such as “there is x amount in this bank account”) at a specific point in time.

But an audited confirmation would require much more detail, such as is this account used to back said stablecoin? Who has access? How are issuance and redemptions handled? Does the company comply with KYC/AML regulations? An “audit” is technically an assurance that a statement is presented according to established standards. These do not yet cover reserve backing of stablecoins.

Even when auditors have “confirmed” stablecoin backing, such as Grant Thornton did for Circle earlier this year, it has been in the form of an attestation. Stablecoin issuer TrueUSD has gone a step further, partnering with a San Francisco-based accounting firm to offer real-time confirmation of reserves, or a “continuous attest.”

Attestations do not give the comfort of audits, though. They are snapshots, not deep dives of due diligence. And while we may soon see standards evolve that encourage official validation of stablecoin processes, for now, auditors seem to be playing it safe.

Why, when there is obviously an increasingly urgent need for the service?

Part of the answer can be seen in another piece of news from last week: crypto custodian BitGo was granted the SOC 2 Type 2 certification, which confirms that it passed a security audit performed by an external monitor. This was performed by one of the Big Four auditing companies (Deloitte, KPMG, PwC and EY) – but BitGo didn’t want to say which one.

It’s possible that the auditor in question wanted to keep a low profile. While all Big Four firms have considerable blockchain teams, one thing is understanding and helping to build applications for a technology – resting your reputation on a public statement, especially when the processes and risks to be validated are notoriously complex, is another thing altogether.

Especially these days, when the accounting profession as a whole is coming under increased scrutiny for quality and trust issues. The role of accountants in the crash of 2008 is still a bone of contention, and the emergence of conflicts of interest has prompted European regulators to call for a break-up of the Big Four. It is understandable that – with some exceptions – they are reluctant to be publicly associated with assets that regulators have not yet fully embraced.

A new skyline

But the Bitfinex mess highlights the need for greater quality control. The sector’s lack of authoritative support from reputable accounting firms can potentially do as much damage as the lack of high-level banking, in that it undermines confidence which in turn will slow down adoption and investment.

The efforts of BitGo and others in getting certifications, and those of the firms supporting them, is appreciated. The sector needs more examples of rigor and compliance if it is to attract the attention of large institutions.

Yet it also needs public support from banks and auditors, not just quiet contracts. It needs more reputable names to be willing to acknowledge relationships. This will boost the confidence of investors – both retail and institutional – in demanding demonstrations of operational quality, which will in turn make the sector more resilient to quakes like the Bitfinex news, and to the aftershocks as more revelations come to light.

As weak structures tumble, more solid edifices will emerge out of the rubble. And around them will spring new ecosystems and networks that encourage more discovery and development, supported by institutions that have already stood the test of time.

Clock image via Shutterstock


Interested in receiving a weekly email with updates on market infrastructure, regulation and institutional crypto products? Sign up for our free Institutional Crypto newsletter here. 

Credit: Source link

Tags: BusinessCryptoCrypto Business
Share76Tweet48
Previous Post

Ethereum Stablecoin DAI Is Trending Towards Its Highly Sought Dollar Value

Next Post

Blockchain’s Adoption Challenge Is a Human Problem, Not Technical

coinnewsdaily

coinnewsdaily

CoinNewsDaily.com is an online Crypto Coin News Website that aims to provide latest trendy news from market and around the world.

Related Posts

ygg sea surpasses 10,000 scholarships in just six months of launch
Alt Coin

YGG SEA Surpasses 10,000 Scholarships in Just Six Months of Launch

May 6, 2022
5 projects enabling smart contract development on bitcoin
Alt Coin

5 Projects Enabling Smart Contract Development on Bitcoin

April 29, 2022
cross chain services play a crucial role in facilitating continued adoption of defi applications
Alt Coin

Cross-Chain Services Play a Crucial Role in Facilitating Continued Adoption of DeFi Applications

April 26, 2022
justin sun launches usdd, integrating the blockchain world and the real world with the decentralized stablecoin
Alt Coin

Justin Sun Launches USDD, Integrating the Blockchain World and the Real World with the Decentralized Stablecoin

April 25, 2022
what are wrapped tokens?
Bitcoin

What Are Wrapped Tokens?

April 23, 2022
what is the future of ethereum (eth)?
Alt Coin

What is the future of Ethereum (ETH)?

April 22, 2022
Load More
Next Post
Blockchain’s Adoption Challenge Is a Human Problem, Not Technical

Blockchain's Adoption Challenge Is a Human Problem, Not Technical

Categories

  • Alt Coin
  • Bitcoin
  • Business
  • Ethereum
  • ICO
  • Litecoin
  • Mining
  • NFT
  • Ripple
  • Tech
  • Trading

What New here?

  • YGG SEA Surpasses 10,000 Scholarships in Just Six Months of Launch
  • Mintable Launches Industry Changing Gas Free Minting Service on Ethereum
  • 5 Projects Enabling Smart Contract Development on Bitcoin

Subscribe to Get More!

Loading
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy & Policy

© 2018-2021 CoinNewsDaily.com by CoinNewsDaily Inc. Crafted with Love by iFtiDev

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining

© 2018-2021 CoinNewsDaily.com by CoinNewsDaily Inc. Crafted with Love by iFtiDev

  • bitcoinBitcoin(BTC)$21,034.00-1.27%
  • ethereumEthereum(ETH)$1,225.590.33%
  • tetherTether(USDT)$1.00-0.17%
  • binancecoinBNB(BNB)$239.540.52%
  • rippleXRP(XRP)$0.349512-3.74%
  • cardanoCardano(ADA)$0.491352-2.44%
  • SolanaSolana(SOL)$39.39-2.25%
  • dogecoinDogecoin(DOGE)$0.071965-6.02%
  • polkadotPolkadot(DOT)$7.89-2.65%
  • Shiba InuShiba Inu(SHIB)$0.000011-3.38%
  • tronTRON(TRX)$0.068066-1.93%
  • daiDai(DAI)$1.00-0.07%
  • leo-tokenLEO Token(LEO)$5.80-1.33%
  • matic-networkPolygon(MATIC)$0.55-5.57%
  • litecoinLitecoin(LTC)$56.29-2.72%
  • FTXFTX(FTT)$27.51-0.95%
  • CronosCronos(CRO)$0.126389-0.20%
  • OKBOKB(OKB)$12.43-1.45%
  • chainlinkChainlink(LINK)$6.69-2.42%
  • stellarStellar(XLM)$0.120236-2.33%
  • cosmosCosmos Hub(ATOM)$7.93-5.62%
  • algorandAlgorand(ALGO)$0.335344-1.94%
  • ethereum-classicEthereum Classic(ETC)$16.71-2.15%
  • moneroMonero(XMR)$122.13-4.46%
  • bitcoin-cashBitcoin Cash(BCH)$111.63-3.42%
  • vechainVeChain(VET)$0.0251450.53%
  • tezosTezos(XTZ)$1.654.96%
  • Internet ComputerInternet Computer(ICP)$5.940.20%
  • theta-tokenTheta Network(THETA)$1.36-1.18%
  • filecoinFilecoin(FIL)$5.89-2.11%
  • ElrondElrond(EGLD)$56.48-1.95%
  • bitcoin-cash-svBitcoin SV(BSV)$59.85-2.70%
  • eosEOS(EOS)$1.00-1.40%
  • AaveAave(AAVE)$68.593.00%
  • makerMaker(MKR)$1,015.09-2.83%
  • paxos-standardPax Dollar(USDP)$1.00-0.24%
  • huobi-tokenHuobi(HT)$5.29-0.82%
  • iotaIOTA(MIOTA)$0.292458-0.66%
  • zcashZcash(ZEC)$62.32-5.61%
  • neoNEO(NEO)$9.57-2.27%
  • zilliqaZilliqa(ZIL)$0.044144-5.05%
  • basic-attention-tokenBasic Attention(BAT)$0.397899-1.53%
  • wavesWaves(WAVES)$5.82-4.40%
  • havvenSynthetix Network(SNX)$2.45-10.82%
  • dashDash(DASH)$49.36-2.49%
  • PancakeSwapPancakeSwap(CAKE)$3.37-0.78%
  • KusamaKusama(KSM)$54.22-1.36%
  • nemNEM(XEM)$0.0425961.61%
  • Elrond ERDElrond ERD(ERD)$0.0259290.00%
  • CompoundCompound(COMP)$50.77-1.61%
  • ethlendAave [OLD](LEND)$4.103.48%
  • qtumQtum(QTUM)$3.05-0.61%
  • bitcoin-goldBitcoin Gold(BTG)$17.21-1.69%
  • omisegoOMG Network(OMG)$2.032.24%
  • golemGolem(GLM)$0.2533014.27%
  • SushiSushi(SUSHI)$1.18-0.70%
  • ontologyOntology(ONT)$0.2524723.49%
  • yearn-financeyearn.finance(YFI)$6,133.39-8.16%
  • umaUMA(UMA)$2.72-1.25%
  • digibyteDigiByte(DGB)$0.010128-4.26%
  • UniswapUniswap(UNI)$2.4438.80%
Posting....