• Latest
SEC Blasts Kik’s ‘Void for Vagueness’ Defense of 2017 ICO

SEC Blasts Kik’s ‘Void for Vagueness’ Defense of 2017 ICO

October 29, 2019
ygg sea surpasses 10,000 scholarships in just six months of launch

YGG SEA Surpasses 10,000 Scholarships in Just Six Months of Launch

May 6, 2022
mintable launches industry changing gas free minting service on ethereum

Mintable Launches Industry Changing Gas Free Minting Service on Ethereum

May 1, 2022
5 projects enabling smart contract development on bitcoin

5 Projects Enabling Smart Contract Development on Bitcoin

April 29, 2022
bitcoin atm installed in mexico's senate building

Bitcoin ATM installed in Mexico’s Senate Building

April 27, 2022
cross chain services play a crucial role in facilitating continued adoption of defi applications

Cross-Chain Services Play a Crucial Role in Facilitating Continued Adoption of DeFi Applications

April 26, 2022
justin sun launches usdd, integrating the blockchain world and the real world with the decentralized stablecoin

Justin Sun Launches USDD, Integrating the Blockchain World and the Real World with the Decentralized Stablecoin

April 25, 2022
nfts: the next musical revolution

NFTs: The Next Musical Revolution

April 24, 2022
things you should know before investing in nfts

Things You Should Know Before Investing in NFTs

April 24, 2022
what are wrapped tokens?

What Are Wrapped Tokens?

April 23, 2022
what is the future of ethereum (eth)?

What is the future of Ethereum (ETH)?

April 22, 2022
green gaming

Everything You Need to Know About Play-to-Earn on Algorand in 2022

April 21, 2022
$ape going bananas as rumors of upcoming land sale of bayc metaverse gather momentum

$APE Going Bananas As Rumors of Upcoming Land Sale of BAYC Metaverse Gather Momentum

April 21, 2022
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining
CoinNewsDaily
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining
No Result
View All Result
CoinNewsDaily
No Result
View All Result
Home Business

SEC Blasts Kik’s ‘Void for Vagueness’ Defense of 2017 ICO

coinnewsdaily by coinnewsdaily
October 29, 2019
in Business
0
SEC Blasts Kik’s ‘Void for Vagueness’ Defense of 2017 ICO
190
SHARES
1.5k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Related articles

ygg sea surpasses 10,000 scholarships in just six months of launch

YGG SEA Surpasses 10,000 Scholarships in Just Six Months of Launch

May 6, 2022
5 projects enabling smart contract development on bitcoin

5 Projects Enabling Smart Contract Development on Bitcoin

April 29, 2022

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) said Kik’s August defense of its $100 million initial coin offering (ICO) was “untenable” and is asking judges to toss it.

A discovery motion filed Monday further raised the stakes, following the SEC’s 49-page filing Friday – the latest play in a legal chess match with sweeping potential ramifications for tokens and securities law, and one seeking, more specifically, to determine whether Kik’s 2017 ICO was lawful.

In Friday’s filing, the SEC ridiculed Kik’s defense that vagueness shields them from legal woes:

“This defense asserts that, notwithstanding 70-plus years of well-settled jurisprudence, the term ‘investment contract’ in the securities laws is void for vagueness as applied to Kik’s investment scheme. This claim is untenable and should be dismissed.”

Kik has bet the farm on a “void for vagueness” affirmative defense, and wants to depose high-ranking SEC officials to prove the regulator was not in a position in 2017 to give clear guidance on token sales.

Rebecca Rettig, a partner at FisherBroyles, told CoinDesk:

“Kik is obviously using the void for vagueness defense as a way to try to peek behind the curtain at the SEC to figure out if the SEC really had a plan all along.”

But the SEC argued in the same discovery motion that Kik’s affirmative defense is without legal merit. The regulator tied their argument to Friday’s flaying of the “void for vagueness” question, arguing Kik’s deposition’s motions “should be quashed.”

If the judges agree, Rettig says the SEC will “kill two birds with one stone.”

What is an investment contract, anyhow?

The SEC’s quarrel with Kik is more than semantics. It drives into decades of legal wrangling over what constitutes an “investment contract.” Kik claims vagueness precludes it from applying to their sale; the SEC says just the opposite.

But what is an investment contract?

Investment contracts are not actually defined in Section 5 of the Securities Act of 1933 – the backbone of U.S. securities law. But in the 1946 Supreme Court case SEC v. Howey, Justices set a legal framework for the phrase.

They created what is known as the “Howey test.” If a transaction invests in a common enterprise (i.e. a business) with the expectation of profit primarily from the effort of others, it is an investment contract. And therefore: a security. And therefore: it falls under the scope of the SEC.

In its June complaint kicking off this legal saga, the SEC argued Kik’s 2017 ICO was an investment contract sale and therefore fell under agency’s remit to regulate. They further claimed Kik executives knew the sale might catch the SEC’s attention and ire – even before the ICO was publicly announced.

In August, Kik argued the opposite. Denying that their tokens were “investment contracts,” Kik said the term did not apply to their ICO, and if it were, then it would be self-defeating because its vagueness makes it unconstitutional:

“As applied to Kik’s offer and sale of Kin in 2017, the definition of ‘investment contract’ (as urged by the Commission) is hopelessly vague, and leaves the Commission free to engage in arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement in this space.”

Void for vagueness

Kik’s affirmative defense – and the SEC’s recent response – spar over whether the “void for vagueness” doctrine of American constitutional law applies here. “Void for vagueness” is the doctrine that laws must not be indecipherable to people of “ordinary intelligence,” or encourage “arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement.”

Put another way, laws must be easy to understand and precise enough to not apply to everything under the sun. Fail either bar, or both, and a court may well rule the law “void for vagueness” and strike it from the books.

But that might not matter in a business context, the SEC argued, citing the Supreme Court’s 1982 ruling in Village of Hoffman Estates v. Flipside, Hoffman Estates, Inc.

“[E]conomic regulation is subject to a less strict vagueness test because its subject matter is often more narrow, and because businesses, which face economic demands to plan behavior carefully, can be expected to consult relevant legislation in advance of action.”

In Kik’s August defense they argued that they did not have “adequate notice” that the SEC would consider Kin an “investment contract.”

The SEC, however, says that is not so. The DAO Report was released in July 2017 – two months prior to Kik’s September 2017 ICO – setting the ground rules for on-chain investment contracts and thus “provided Kik constitutionally sufficient notice to Kik that the Offering and Sale might violate the Securities Act.”

Rettig said that the SEC sees their July 2017 DAO report  on digital asset securities drew a “bright line” for ICO issuers, said Rettig.

“The SEC says DAO was the line: ‘We issued our DAO report and after that everyone in the digital assets space is on notice that if they were issuing tokens, they better do a Howey analysis and make sure that they weren’t investment contracts. You, Kik, didn’t do that and therefore you violated section 5 of the Securities Act.”

What happens next

Until the court rules on these arguments, and the case, these legal back and forths are mere joists.

A decision could take weeks, or even months, lawyers said. And it took years for the SEC to pursue action against token sales, Kik argues, saying the wild west ICOs of 2016 and 2017 “contributed to the confusion” of this case.

Kik’s strategy is to force a lengthy discovery process with depositions from a range of SEC officials; they argue that documents, and depositions, are relevant to their void for vagueness affirmative defense.

Conversely, the SEC argues that their discovery requests are irrelevant, cover privileged material, and target officials usually exempt from being deposed.

Lawyers representing Kik did not respond to requests for comment Tuesday.

 

SEC Motion for Judgement by CoinDesk on Scribd

 

Discovery Motion SEC vs. KIK by CoinDesk on Scribd

Image via Shutterstock

Credit: Source link

Tags: BusinessCryptoCrypto Business
Share76Tweet48
Previous Post

Lock BTC, Get DAI: Lending Firm Bridges Bitcoin-DeFi Divide in Latin America

Next Post

Chinese State-Owned Media Try to Dampen Market’s Crypto Enthusiasm

coinnewsdaily

coinnewsdaily

CoinNewsDaily.com is an online Crypto Coin News Website that aims to provide latest trendy news from market and around the world.

Related Posts

ygg sea surpasses 10,000 scholarships in just six months of launch
Alt Coin

YGG SEA Surpasses 10,000 Scholarships in Just Six Months of Launch

May 6, 2022
5 projects enabling smart contract development on bitcoin
Alt Coin

5 Projects Enabling Smart Contract Development on Bitcoin

April 29, 2022
cross chain services play a crucial role in facilitating continued adoption of defi applications
Alt Coin

Cross-Chain Services Play a Crucial Role in Facilitating Continued Adoption of DeFi Applications

April 26, 2022
justin sun launches usdd, integrating the blockchain world and the real world with the decentralized stablecoin
Alt Coin

Justin Sun Launches USDD, Integrating the Blockchain World and the Real World with the Decentralized Stablecoin

April 25, 2022
what are wrapped tokens?
Bitcoin

What Are Wrapped Tokens?

April 23, 2022
what is the future of ethereum (eth)?
Alt Coin

What is the future of Ethereum (ETH)?

April 22, 2022
Load More
Next Post
Chinese State-Owned Media Try to Dampen Market’s Crypto Enthusiasm

Chinese State-Owned Media Try to Dampen Market's Crypto Enthusiasm

Categories

  • Alt Coin
  • Bitcoin
  • Business
  • Ethereum
  • ICO
  • Litecoin
  • Mining
  • NFT
  • Ripple
  • Tech
  • Trading

What New here?

  • YGG SEA Surpasses 10,000 Scholarships in Just Six Months of Launch
  • Mintable Launches Industry Changing Gas Free Minting Service on Ethereum
  • 5 Projects Enabling Smart Contract Development on Bitcoin
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy & Policy

© 2018-2021 CoinNewsDaily.com by CoinNewsDaily Inc. Crafted with Love by iFtiDev

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining

© 2018-2021 CoinNewsDaily.com by CoinNewsDaily Inc. Crafted with Love by iFtiDev

  • bitcoinBitcoin(BTC)$27,858.000.83%
  • ethereumEthereum(ETH)$1,763.360.84%
  • tetherTether(USDT)$1.00-0.67%
  • binancecoinBNB(BNB)$327.880.86%
  • rippleXRP(XRP)$0.448272-2.63%
  • cardanoCardano(ADA)$0.354797-0.26%
  • dogecoinDogecoin(DOGE)$0.074192-0.50%
  • matic-networkPolygon(MATIC)$1.101.83%
  • solanaSolana(SOL)$20.861.81%
  • polkadotPolkadot(DOT)$6.021.18%
  • litecoinLitecoin(LTC)$92.730.98%
  • shiba-inuShiba Inu(SHIB)$0.0000110.12%
  • tronTRON(TRX)$0.0643070.69%
  • daiDai(DAI)$1.00-0.36%
  • chainlinkChainlink(LINK)$7.242.17%
  • cosmosCosmos Hub(ATOM)$11.240.61%
  • leo-tokenLEO Token(LEO)$3.462.75%
  • moneroMonero(XMR)$160.79-1.28%
  • ethereum-classicEthereum Classic(ETC)$20.331.08%
  • okbOKB(OKB)$41.931.62%
  • stellarStellar(XLM)$0.0921340.72%
  • bitcoin-cashBitcoin Cash(BCH)$124.15-1.14%
  • filecoinFilecoin(FIL)$5.654.23%
  • crypto-com-chainCronos(CRO)$0.0692450.48%
  • vechainVeChain(VET)$0.022784-0.19%
  • algorandAlgorand(ALGO)$0.2103371.46%
  • internet-computerInternet Computer(ICP)$4.940.84%
  • eosEOS(EOS)$1.131.28%
  • elrond-erd-2MultiversX(EGLD)$42.510.77%
  • tezosTezos(XTZ)$1.141.73%
  • aaveAave(AAVE)$72.721.75%
  • theta-tokenTheta Network(THETA)$1.010.76%
  • neoNEO(NEO)$12.191.24%
  • paxos-standardPax Dollar(USDP)$1.00-0.62%
  • havvenSynthetix Network(SNX)$2.440.17%
  • bitcoin-cash-svBitcoin SV(BSV)$36.75-0.37%
  • pancakeswap-tokenPancakeSwap(CAKE)$3.740.38%
  • dashDash(DASH)$58.89-0.03%
  • makerMaker(MKR)$672.800.92%
  • huobi-tokenHuobi(HT)$3.691.09%
  • iotaIOTA(MIOTA)$0.2097271.57%
  • zilliqaZilliqa(ZIL)$0.0272661.16%
  • zcashZcash(ZEC)$36.051.84%
  • basic-attention-tokenBasic Attention(BAT)$0.2484955.08%
  • nemNEM(XEM)$0.0392821.55%
  • Elrond ERDElrond ERD(ERD)$0.0259290.00%
  • qtumQtum(QTUM)$3.10-0.26%
  • kusamaKusama(KSM)$33.442.88%
  • compound-governance-tokenCompound(COMP)$42.341.04%
  • bitcoin-goldBitcoin Gold(BTG)$16.37-1.02%
  • yearn-financeyearn.finance(YFI)$8,362.781.13%
  • omisegoOMG Network(OMG)$1.84-1.12%
  • ftx-tokenFTX(FTT)$1.89-21.50%
  • golemGolem(GLM)$0.2400980.71%
  • wavesWaves(WAVES)$2.150.65%
  • ontologyOntology(ONT)$0.2308194.17%
  • sushiSushi(SUSHI)$1.052.99%
  • digibyteDigiByte(DGB)$0.0095970.74%
  • umaUMA(UMA)$2.041.45%
  • ethlendAave [OLD](LEND)$0.53-3.08%
  • UniswapUniswap(UNI)$2.4438.80%