• Latest
A Battle Between Bitcoin Wallets Has Big Implications for Privacy

A Battle Between Bitcoin Wallets Has Big Implications for Privacy

August 6, 2019
6 Questions for Rene Reinsberg of Celo – Cointelegraph Magazine

6 Questions for Rene Reinsberg of Celo – Cointelegraph Magazine

März 31, 2023
Judge denies SEC motion to keep Hinman docs secret in Ripple case

Judge denies SEC motion to keep Hinman docs secret in Ripple case

März 31, 2023
The ultimate guide to Miami – Cointelegraph Magazine

The ultimate guide to Miami – Cointelegraph Magazine

März 31, 2023
Dr. Jane Thomason – Cointelegraph Magazine

Dr. Jane Thomason – Cointelegraph Magazine

März 31, 2023
1658007797 celsius is bankrupt with 12b balance sheet hole su zhu.jpg

Celsius is bankrupt with $1.2B balance sheet hole, Su Zhu returns to Twitter and OpenSea purges 20% of employees: Hodler’s Digest, July 10-16

März 31, 2023
6 Questions for Lisa Fridman of Quadrata – Cointelegraph Magazine

6 Questions for Lisa Fridman of Quadrata – Cointelegraph Magazine

März 31, 2023
Jed McCaleb empties XRP wallet after eight-year selloff

Jed McCaleb empties XRP wallet after eight-year selloff

März 31, 2023
Celsius has finally filed for bankruptcy: Law Decoded, July 18-25

Celsius has finally filed for bankruptcy: Law Decoded, July 18-25

März 31, 2023
The ‘godfather of crypto’ risked lifetime in jail, laying foundation for Bitcoin – Cointelegraph Magazine

The ‘godfather of crypto’ risked lifetime in jail, laying foundation for Bitcoin – Cointelegraph Magazine

März 31, 2023
SEC objects to XRP holders aiding Ripple defense

SEC objects to XRP holders aiding Ripple defense

März 31, 2023
Blockchain technology is transforming the real estate market – Cointelegraph Magazine

Blockchain technology is transforming the real estate market – Cointelegraph Magazine

März 31, 2023
1658612147 nfts banned in minecraft sec lists 9 tokens as securities.jpg

NFTs banned in Minecraft, SEC lists 9 tokens as securities and 3AC founder blames cockyness for company meltdown: Hodler’s Digest, July 17-23

März 31, 2023
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining
CoinNewsDaily
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining
No Result
View All Result
CoinNewsDaily
No Result
View All Result
Home Tech

A Battle Between Bitcoin Wallets Has Big Implications for Privacy

coinnewsdaily by coinnewsdaily
August 6, 2019
in Tech
0
A Battle Between Bitcoin Wallets Has Big Implications for Privacy
190
SHARES
1.5k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Bitcoin privacy wallet Samourai announced last Thursday that its primary competitor, Wasabi Wallet, is the target of an ongoing network attack.

The blog post is the latest in a string of allegations Samourai has leveled against Wasabi since mid-July.

Related articles

Bankman-Fried faces down roomful of futures industry insiders at CFTC roundtable

Bankman-Fried faces down roomful of futures industry insiders at CFTC roundtable

Mai 25, 2022
Central African Republic to launch official crypto hub ‘Sango’

Central African Republic to launch official crypto hub ‘Sango’

Mai 24, 2022

The attack, according to Samourai Wallet, resembles a Sybil attack, where a small number of users falsifies new identities and pretends to be much larger in number. This would mean that the anonymity set, or crowd, in which a user can hide their bitcoin transactions is not actually as large as Wasabi suggests.

“As the Wasabi team has described it, the goal of the Wasabi mixing technique, is to hide your [unspent transaction outputs] in a ‘sufficiently’ large crowd (peers),” Samourai wrote in its blog post. “The current target Anonymity Set in Wasabi mixing is 100 peers.”

That means that if, say, 20 of those peers are actually just one user and the identity of this user is uncovered, privacy levels for all other users in the same mixing pool are reduced.

“With bad user privacy, the crowd gets smaller,” independent bitcoin researcher Max Hillebrand explained to CoinDesk. “If you are one of these other [transactions] that have not been de-anonymized [by an attacker] then your anonymity set is no longer 100.”

Samourai says evidence of Sybil attacks on the Wasabi network dates back to January 2019.

Wasabi has issued its own statements refuting Samourai’s claims, while also issuing allegations of their own against Samourai.

As a result, privacy-minded bitcoin users are questioning the true efficacy of either wallet in hiding the identities of its users.

CoinJoin’ed history

Indeed, the core design of both Samourai and Wasabi actually has more in common than most realize.

Speaking to CoinDesk, the co-founder of Samourai Wallet, who goes by the initials SW, said that at one point in time, Samourai and Wasabi were the same application.

Lead developers TDevD (Samourai) and nopara73 (Wasabi) worked together on building an implementation of long-standing bitcoin privacy tech CoinJoin called ZeroLink.

“We just had a difference in implementation desire,” said SW. “So we split. We forked the project and just implemented it the way we wanted to implement it.”

Samourai’s implementation of ZeroLink (called Whirlpool) has a different pricing mechanism than Wasabi, though this is not the only difference between the two wallet applications. As a result, SW maintains that Whirlpool makes it more expensive for malicious actors in the system to break the anonymity of other users through a Sybil attack.

‘This is madness’

Wasabi’s Adam Ficsor, who goes by the alias nopara73, counters that divvying up costs later on in the process is actually more “cost-effective” and points out that anonymity using Whirlpool can always be broken given that Samourai relies on a centralized, backend server to process users’ extended public keys.

“Fuck you,” Ficsor wrote in a Medium post on July 21. “How can you take a stupid design decision you made and act like it’d be a significant advantage over another project that clearly has its basics right?”

This issue of sending user addresses to a backend server, Fiscor said in a second blog post, was raised by the creator of CoinJoin, Gregory Maxwell. When Maxwell approached the Samourai team with his concerns, he said on Reddit he was harassed and accused of making false claims.

“When you use the wallet, you send Samourai all of your public keys in the form of an extended public key (XPUB) that let’s Samourai have unique access to all of your current and future addresses,” said Aviv Milner, the community technical support lead for the startup behind Wasabi, zkSNACKs.

This matter of Samourai’s reliance on a backend server is one that SW admits does require the trust of users “that Samourai isn’t trying to sell their public key data to third parties.”

‘Always mix’

As such, experts say there is no clear winner between Wasabi and Samourai.

“[The two] are based on different assumptions,” Hillebrand said, adding:

“One assumes that the coordinator must not be trusted and that everyone knows what the coordinator knows. The other assumption is that there is an inherent trust in the developers and therefore it’s OK to trust central servers. Now, [what you choose] really depends on the threat model of every individual and each unique case.”

According to Hillebrand, while the basics of the two ZeroLink implementations are the same, in both implementations users are required to take privacy matters into their own hands by ensuring they are abiding by the best practices of the protocol.

Indeed, Kevin Loaec, the managing director of blockchain consultancy Chainsmiths, said any CoinJoin implementation will suffer from the same basic attack vectors.

“Privacy on bitcoin is extremely hard, any mistake from you or other mixing participants will hunt you down in the future as the blockchain is here for all to see,” Loaec told CoinDesk. “The type of wallet you use, the spending habits (time of the day, amounts…) the consolidations you do… everything can be exploited to profile you and reduce the anonymity.”

As such, Loaec, who uses both Wasabi and Samourai wallets, said that for users still deciding on which side of the bitcoin privacy wallet debate to land, there isn’t one right answer.

Concluded Loaec:

“Use CoinJoin, but learn about it and don’t assume you are private. Always mix.”

Image via Shutterstock 

Credit: Source link

Share76Tweet48
Previous Post

Price Analysis 05/08: BTC, ETH, XRP, LTC, BCH, BNB, EOS, BSV, XLM, XMR

Next Post

Facebook Hires US Senator’s Former Aide to Lobby for Libra Cryptocurrency

coinnewsdaily

coinnewsdaily

CoinNewsDaily.com is an online Crypto Coin News Website that aims to provide latest trendy news from market and around the world.

Related Posts

Bankman-Fried faces down roomful of futures industry insiders at CFTC roundtable
Tech

Bankman-Fried faces down roomful of futures industry insiders at CFTC roundtable

Mai 25, 2022
Central African Republic to launch official crypto hub ‘Sango’
Tech

Central African Republic to launch official crypto hub ‘Sango’

Mai 24, 2022
South Korean police request exchanges freeze LFG related funds
Tech

South Korean police request exchanges freeze LFG related funds

Mai 24, 2022
Bitcoin stands apart from other crypto, and what that means for US public policy
Tech

Bitcoin stands apart from other crypto, and what that means for US public policy

Mai 22, 2022
Needed: A massive education project to fight hacks and scams
Tech

Needed: A massive education project to fight hacks and scams

Mai 21, 2022
Commonwealth Bank puts crypto trading trial on ice as regulators dither
Tech

Commonwealth Bank puts crypto trading trial on ice as regulators dither

Mai 20, 2022
Load More
Next Post
Facebook Hires US Senator’s Former Aide to Lobby for Libra Cryptocurrency

Facebook Hires US Senator's Former Aide to Lobby for Libra Cryptocurrency

Kategorien

  • Alt Coin
  • Bitcoin
  • Business
  • Ethereum
  • ICO
  • Litecoin
  • Mining
  • NFT
  • Ripple
  • Tech
  • Trading

What New here?

  • 6 Questions for Rene Reinsberg of Celo – Cointelegraph Magazine
  • Judge denies SEC motion to keep Hinman docs secret in Ripple case
  • The ultimate guide to Miami – Cointelegraph Magazine
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy & Policy

© 2018-2021 CoinNewsDaily.com by CoinNewsDaily Inc. Crafted with Love by iFtiDev

Please enter CoinMarketCap Free Api Key to get this plugin works.
✕
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Coin Market Cap
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Ripple
  • Litecoin
  • Alt Coin
  • Business
  • Trading
  • Mining

© 2018-2021 CoinNewsDaily.com by CoinNewsDaily Inc. Crafted with Love by iFtiDev